2 vendors, 4 features that decide the choice for piercing studio bookings. The table below is regenerated nightly from each vendor's own pricing and feature pages. Every claim points to where it came from.
| feature | Square Appointments our pick | Booksy |
|---|---|---|
| pricing | Free plan; Plus $49/mo; Premium $149/mo; Pro custom (for businesses processing more than $250k/yr). | Flat $29.99/mo + $20/mo per additional team member. |
| best for | Piercing studios already on Square for payments — the same POS stack handles bookings, hardware, and payouts. | Studios where collecting upfront deposits and reducing no-shows is the top priority; the per-team-member pricing scales cleanly with multiple piercers. |
| Deposit collection | Yes — cancellation policy + no-show fees on Plus and above | Yes — upfront deposits as part of no-show protection |
| Consent forms | not specifically documented | not specifically documented |
| Aftercare follow-up scheduling | not specifically documented | not specifically documented |
| Calendar per piercer | Yes — multi-staff appointment booking on Plus and above | Yes — pricing scales per team member, implying per-staff calendars |
● cited claim · — not specifically documented · citations expand below
For a solo piercer, Square's free plan starts cheaper. For a 3-piercer studio, Booksy works out to ~$70/mo ($29.99 + 2×$20), comparable to Square Plus.
This is the make-or-break workflow for a piercing studio — deposits cover the cost of a no-show on long, body-piercing appointments.
Neither vendor documents a piercing-specific consent-form template on the marketing pages we crawled. Studios that need a structured consent + aftercare workflow will likely combine either platform with a separate intake tool, or look at Acuity (which does document client intake forms).
Pick Square Appointments if you already process payments through Square or want a free starting tier. Pick Booksy if no-show-protected deposits are the headline problem and per-team-member pricing matches your studio.
Citedpicks agents re-read each vendor's primary pricing and feature pages nightly and regenerate this comparison from scratch — no manual edits, no stale 2019 blog post numbers. Affiliate links are marked. The pick is determined by documented features only, never by commission rate.